20 States Where Car Insurance Costs Over $3000 a Year

For drivers in certain parts of the United States, paying over $3,000 per year for car insurance is simply the harsh reality. A variety of factors influence auto insurance pricing, leading to major disparities between states. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the 20 states where average annual car insurance premiums surpass the $3,000 mark and explore strategies to keep your costs as low as possible.

States Where Car Insurance Costs Over $3000 a Year

Key Takeaways

  • Michigan tops the list with annual premiums averaging $5,766 due to its unique no-fault system with unlimited medical benefits.
  • States prone to severe weather like Florida, as well as urban areas with high population density, tend to have higher rates.
  • Shopping around, taking advantage of discounts, raising deductibles, and maintaining a clean driving record can help offset high insurance costs.

20 States Where Car Insurance Costs Over $3,000 a Year

According to the latest data, these are the 20 states where average car insurance premiums exceed $3,000 per year for a full coverage policy:

State Average Annual Premium
Michigan $5,766
New Jersey $4,316
Louisiana $4,280
Kentucky $4,200
New York $4,200
Florida $3,766
Delaware $3,759
Rhode Island $3,494
Maryland $3,308
Nevada $3,250
Kansas $3,246
Missouri $3,225
Colorado $3,220
Arizona $3,218
South Dakota $3,217
South Carolina $3,133
Oklahoma $3,109
West Virginia $3,075
Connecticut $3,028
Georgia $3,009

As the data illustrates, many of the costliest states cluster along the eastern seaboard and Gulf Coast regions. However, several inland states like Michigan, Colorado, and Kansas also make an appearance on this undesirable list.

Why Car Insurance is So Expensive in These States

While specific circumstances vary from state to state, several common factors contribute to the exorbitant car insurance rates seen in these 21 locations:

Population Density and Urban Areas

Densely populated urban centers inherently pose a higher risk for accidents, vehicle theft, and other incidents that lead to insurance claims. States like New York, New Jersey, Florida, and Maryland are home to several major metropolitan areas, driving up rates for all residents.

No-Fault Insurance Laws

A handful of states on the list, including Michigan, Florida, New Jersey, New York, and others, have adopted no-fault insurance systems. These laws require drivers to file claims with their own insurance provider for medical expenses resulting from an accident, regardless of who was at fault.

In Michigan’s case, the state takes no-fault a step further by mandating unlimited personal injury protection (PIP) coverage. This provision has significantly increased costs, as insurers must be prepared to cover a driver’s medical bills for life following a severe accident.

Severe Weather Risks

Natural disasters wreak havoc in many forms, from hurricanes and tornadoes to hail storms and flooding. States frequented by these destructive weather events, like Florida and Louisiana, inevitably face higher comprehensive claim costs. As insurance providers cover the losses, they raise rates to offset the risks.

How to Get Affordable Car Insurance Rates

While residing in one of the priciest states undoubtedly makes obtaining cheap car insurance an uphill battle, drivers still have several tactics at their disposal to minimize costs:

Shop Around for Quotes

Perhaps the most crucial step is to compare quotes from multiple insurance providers, as pricing algorithms can vary drastically between companies. What may be considered a high-risk driver by one insurer could be viewed as relatively low-risk by another.

Even in the most expensive states, there are usually a few companies offering comparatively affordable rates. Be diligent about gathering at least 3-5 quotes to find the bargain policies.

Take Advantage of Discounts

From good driver and defensive driving course discounts to potential savings for insuring multiple vehicles or bundling policies, there are numerous opportunities to shave dollars off your premium. Inquire about all available discounts from each insurance company and be prepared to provide documentation as needed.

Raise Your Deductible

One of the quickest ways to reduce your annual premium is by increasing the deductible amount on your collision and comprehensive coverages. By agreeing to cover more of the cost out-of-pocket following an incident, you can potentially save 40% or more on these policy components.

However, it’s essential to set the deductible at a level you could realistically afford in the event of a claim. Many experts recommend saving enough to cover the deductible in an emergency fund.

Maintain a Good Driving Record

Safe driving isn’t just smart for avoiding accidents—it’s also the key to keeping your car insurance rates in check. Reckless behavior like speeding tickets and at-fault collisions can cause massive premium spikes that compound annually. Stay focused behind the wheel and be diligent about adhering to traffic laws.

Bundle Policies

If you need home, renters, or another line of insurance beyond just auto coverage, bundling these policies under the same provider can net you a decent discount. Many insurers offer bundling incentives to new customers as well as existing policyholders who add additional coverages.

How to Identify the Cheapest Car Insurance in Your State

Even in the most expensive states for car insurance, there’s bound to be at least a couple of companies offering rates well below the state average. To pinpoint these bargains:

  • Leverage online quote tools to instantly compare estimates from several major insurers at once. Be prepared to enter information about your vehicle, driving history, desired coverages, and other relevant details.
  • Check consumer review sites, rating agencies, and other impartial sources to gauge each provider’s reputation for affordability and customer satisfaction.
  • Consider usage-based or pay-per-mile programs from insurers like Metromile, which can translate into substantial savings for low-mileage drivers.
  • Work with an independent agent who can provide unbiased advice and rate comparisons across multiple companies.

When to Expect Rate Increases

While the 21 states above may hold the ignominious title of priciest auto insurance hotspots today, that doesn’t mean your rates are frozen indefinitely. Insurance companies raise rates annually in an attempt to keep pace with:

  • Inflation: As the cost of providing insurance goes up due to broader economic factors, those price hikes get passed along through premium increases.
  • Rising repair costs: Newer vehicles are more advanced and expensive to repair, resulting in higher claim payouts that insurers must account for.
  • Weather events: A major hurricane, flood, or wildfire can trigger a flurry of comprehensive claims. To recoup these losses, carriers hike rates accordingly.

Most policyholders experience their annual rate adjustment upon renewal, though the specific timing can vary by company. If your premium seems to be skyrocketing, it may be time to revisit shopping around for a better deal.

Car Insurance Laws to Know

When it comes to auto insurance requirements, each state has its own set of laws determining minimum coverage levels and other provisions. While most follow a traditional fault-based system centered on bodily injury and property damage liability, some unique situations exist:

  • No-fault states: As discussed earlier, states like Michigan, Florida, and New York require PIP coverage, restricting drivers’ ability to sue following an accident except in certain situations.
  • Vehicle protection requirements: In Michigan, all policies must include $1 million of property protection insurance (PPI) to cover damage to buildings, fences, and other structures resulting from a crash.
  • Low minimums: Some states have kept required liability minimums quite low compared to others. For example, Florida only mandates 10/20/10 (up to $10,000 per person/$20,000 per accident for injuries and $10,000 for property damage).

Before purchasing or renewing a policy, reviewing your specific state’s insurance laws can prove invaluable in understanding your rights, requirements, and options as a consumer.

While residing in one of the 21 most expensive states for car insurance is certainly a frustrating predicament for drivers, there’s no need to resign yourself to sky

More Related Content


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here